Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Cheese Pizza (Medium 14")
Cheese Pizza (Large 18")
Cheese Pizza
Cheese Pizza (10")
About
Vinny's Pizza - St. Augustine
Welcome to Vinny's Pizza - St. Augustine, where every bite tells a delicious story! Nestled at 105 Yacht Club Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32084, this local gem is rapidly becoming a favorite for pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike. Whether you’re grabbing a slice on the go or enjoying a meal with friends, Vinny's offers a delightful pizza experience that resonates with both the casual diner and hardcore food aficionados.
From the moment you step inside, you are greeted with a warm welcome and the comforting scent of freshly baked pizza. The menu radiates classic flavors and innovative choices alike. Customer reviews highlight perhaps the star of the show—the crust. A fluffy yet crispy base is critical in pizza making, and patrons rave about its texture and taste. As one satisfied customer, Barbara Wood, notes, the crust at Vinny's is nothing short of perfection—“nice and fluffy soft but crispy to perfection.” The dedicated staff crafts each pizza with skill and care, ensuring that every bite is both satisfying and memorable.
Vinny’s doesn't just stop at traditional offerings. For those craving a little more creativity, their new Signature Pizzas provide a delightful twist. Choose from options like BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, or Chicken Alfredo—each bursting with flavor for just US$21.99 for an 18” pie. And for those who like to dip their toes in variety, the cheese pizza by the slice is a steal at only US$2.50! Perfect for the on-the-go adventurer or the pickiest of eaters, you’re sure to find a pizza that conquers your taste buds.
Beverages are straightforward and refreshing, with soft drinks available at US$1.95. However, what truly stands out is the customer service—locals like Amber Steele rave about the care Vinny's takes in ensuring their orders are delivered with quality, proving that this establishment goes above and beyond for its patrons.
For those in search of new culinary experiences, don’t miss out on their white pizza, praised for its rich and creamy ricotta topping. As Nicole Wittkopp pointed out, it’s a revelation for first-timers that leaves diners wishing for another slice! Other unique offerings, like their delectable garlic knots and pizza rolls, also entice many to return for another serving.
In a city brimming with history and charm, Vinny's Pizza - St. Augustine manages to capture the essence of great dining—friendly service, fantastic flavors, and an inviting atmosphere. Whether you're a local or just passing through, take a moment to indulge in the magic of their pizzas. After all, as Barbara hints, you might just find yourself willing to drive hours for that perfect slice!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We bought an extra large pepperoni pizza, and 3 bottled drinks, On our way to catch the stargazing night boat tour. Unfortunately for us, we did not plan enough time to be able to enjoy the entire pizza. We each were able to eat just one slice before the the tour took place. The rest had to go in the trash sadly. However it was the most delicious pizza I've had in a while. My fiance and I, are both kind of snobs when it comes to Pizza, as we both have worked in the industry. The crust can really make or break a pizza and most people never even realize it. This crust was so delicious, nice and fluffy soft but crispy to perfection... IYKYK!!! My only regret is that we did not find this place sooner on our trip! I absolutely would have loved to have tried your garlic knots! You guys have me wanting to drive 3 hours to come to a Pizza place. I might just have to take that trip! Anyways, if you have read all my babbling this far, I highly recommend trying Vinny's! ”
“ If you’re local, this place delivers and is so great! Pizza cooked to perfection, they actually deliver it, not toast or eats or any of the others. It’s also very affordable! ”
“ I’m from Chicago so I know pizza. While Vinny’s is more New York than Chicago, it is excellent pizza. We stay in St Augustine area about two months each year and we take out from Vinny’s several times. Highly recommend the cheese pizza and any of the salads. Don’t like the sausage pizza and the meatballs used to be larger and better. Stick to pizza and salad and you will be happy. ”
“ 5 stars across the board. First you are greeted with a warm welcome. Cosmo took our order and provided insight into both the fresh ingredients and the preparation of our selections. Cosmo was assisted by another gentleman, Cole. The two pizza artisans prepared a delectable steak wrap, tantalizing pizza rolls from scratch, an indulgent pizza sub and succulent stuffed shells. Creating an extravaganza of taste and superb dinning experience. Thank you gentlemen, the fantastic evening of delicious delights makes for a perfect end to any day. Owners of Borrillo's. ”
“ First timer to St. Augustine and had to get pizza- the white pizza here was unbelievably delicious! I’ve never had white pizza before with ricotta on top but it slapped! The price was reasonable for the area and the service (I think the owner) was so nice and friendly!! Asked if I needed plates, utensils, extra. Really positive experience all around- wish I could go back!! ”
“ Pizza and garlic knots were sooooo good!! A little pricier than I thought it would be with medium double pepperoni and garlic knots running me 28-30. But it was hot, fresh, and delicious! The staff were very nice. Had the dining area been a little nicer, I would've eaten inside. Will be back next time I visit St. Augustine ”
“ This was our first time getting food from Vinny's. We had just gotten into town and just wanted some take out and we ordered from Vinny's. It was delicious! And the size of the calzone and the meatball sub was huge, but oh so good! We will definitely be getting food there again, the next time we're in town. ”
“ The kid wants some food, and we're too lazy to go far, so we try this place next to our Airbnb. We ordered a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and a meatball spaghetti. The gentleman who took our order was incredibly friendly and even offered us extra plates. Since this was our first order from a non-chain pizza place, we were uncertain about the food. However, we were blown away by how delicious both dishes were! I wholeheartedly recommend that other tourists give this place a chance—you won’t be disappointed! ”